Opinion

In praise of negativity

By on

“I wish there wasn’t so much emphasis on wellbeing at the moment.”


That’s not really a phrase you expect to come across in conversation right now, is it? Surely, we want more emphasis not less? Naturally, I was a bit surprised to hear it from a friend. 

Of course, I had to ask why. It turned out that they didn’t mean quite what I thought. The more we talked about wellbeing, the more I understood. Undoubtedly, my friend wanted to feel well – the problem was that they perceived a pressure to be supremely, permanently, and for them, overbearingly, upbeat, or positive.

Samantha Peters: "Most of us feel grumpy from time to time, some of us are more melancholic than others and yes, everyone has off days."

I don’t believe that’s what wellbeing is about. Nor, I am sure, do you. But still, the perception was there. And what my friend yearned for was respite from it, from a burdensome expectation which they associated with workplace wellness initiatives and wider society.

I vaguely recall how one of author Herman Melville’s characters talked of experiencing a damp, drizzly November in their soul. This autumnal feeling made him feel ‘grim about the mouth’ and prompted the desire to ruminate or run away. What my friend wanted was permission to have off days, moments of negativity, unevenness of mood. She wasn’t necessarily asking others to accept her November moments. She just wanted to not feel guilty about having them.

Which begs a question. How do we ensure that organisational wellbeing strategies underpin employees’ wellness without simultaneously creating unrealistic emotional expectations? How can we help staff navigate their November moments? Clearly, management needs to think about this when designing approaches to wellbeing inside organisations.

There’s a role here for organisational leaders too. To speak out in praise of negativity. I can’t imagine it would be popular. I have always felt the need to be unrelentingly positive and enthusiastic. Boards expect it. Teams need it. Or at least I assume so. But I think we need to get better at seeing the benefit of imperfection. Most of us feel grumpy from time to time, some of us are more melancholic than others and yes, everyone has off days. Moreover, we all make mistakes, and we all face problems and challenges.

I am reminded of Minnesotan band, Cloud Cult. Their lead singer, Craig Minowa, once said that true wisdom comes from balance. That it derives from the things that have burned you as well as those lovelier bubble-gum aspects of life. It is a thought perhaps best expressed in their song, No Hell, in which it’s proclaimed: “The best things we’ve learned, we learned from the wreck.”

My own research shows that negative moods or emotions push us inward, fixing attention on our own circumstances at the expense of colleagues, customers or clients. So, it makes sense to avoid creating negative organisational climates.

But if we seek to eradicate negatives from the workplace completely, what will we lose?

We would be eschewing balance. We might be missing out on life in its fullest, with all its imperfections and what they can teach us. We could even be making wellbeing harder to achieve.

So, accentuate the positive? Yes, absolutely.

Eliminate the negative? No, not always.

Leave space for a little greyness in your soul. You never know what you might gain from it.

Being Well Together programme:
beingwelltogether.org

Samantha Peters is Chair of BSC Being Well Together Committee

OPINION


Portrait Wendy Chamberlain MP

Unpaid carers need a legal right to unpaid leave to support their wellbeing

By Wendy Chamberlain MP on 07 September 2022

Unpaid carers are the backbone of our society. It is a cliché but it is true. There are an estimated 2.3 million people providing care to their family, friends and neighbours around the country.



Mike Robinson (3)MED.jpg

How can we avoid this being a winter of discontent?

By Mike Robinson FCA, British Safety Council on 04 September 2022

We now know the real extent of the rise we can expect in energy prices this autumn. An 80 per cent increase. Just take that in for a moment.



Steve Perkins Headshot Bw Min

It’s time to up our game on preventing occupational diseases

By Steve Perkins, Steve Perkins Associates on 16 August 2022

“What gets measured gets managed.” So said Peter Drucker, the well-known management thinker. And it’s generally true. Unfortunately, when it comes to protecting the physical health of our workers from exposures that cause disease and death, we tend to count the corpses rather than focus on controlling the exposures that produce them.